Chamber Magic was very classic style, and the one I saw when I went. It was excellent.
If I was to go now, I would be very very torn between Derek DelGuadio, Derren Brown (if he's still there), and Dan White's.
Cost may be a factor, and some tickets are harder to get (like Dan's at the Nomad)
And if you are feeling particularly lush, there's the restaurant Eleven Maddison Park. They have a 3 hour dining experience. It's 8-10 courses and is one of the top 50 restaurants in the world. They have course that includes magic (that the team of the Nomad show created). The price is about the same as a good seat at a Broadway show. So if you're a foodie, then it's apparently quite the experience. It's a food experience rather than a theater experience. - and apparently you get a special edition of the monarch decks.