The Mystery Box Lockbox has to be my all-time favorite. Even though I figured out the combination shortly after it was released, I've never opened the box. As soon as the lock opens my heart races and I can't bring myself to move beyond that. The mystery of it has been a great conversation...
There was a somewhat recent Kickstarter campaign that raised $477,000 to reprint Jerry's. I don't know how they compare to the original, but other than the design they feel okay.
My old school favorite T11 deck is the Rebel.
My new school favorite is Contraband.
I feel like they're two decks cut from the same cloth and would love to see some foil...