I agree with Reality one. In the video you were just doing the move. I would think in a trick you would add misdirection while you did that or make an excuse to make that action look normal. From a slight stand point I think it is great.
I like effect 2. Probably possible too.
My effect: The magician has a 2000 piece lego broken apart on the ground. His friend asks him to put it back together. He uses the force and puts it together in fast motion taking under a minute.
This was awesome. Did not think he would win. Thought a singer would. After each reveal of the vote I was saying ok this time Shin will be called. But he didn't!