This is a bit of a tough one to figure out. Here's my two cents on the issue:
Part of it is that, in magic, the good thing to do if you use copyrighted music in a show done for profit is to pay royalties (Although I'm not sure if that gets done a lot). But using an actual trick made by someone else? I mean, its done in busking and street magic all the time and no royalties are paid.
I mean, the same scenario has been done on televised shows like AGT. But I'm not sure how that completely plays out.
My guess is once the trick has been sold by the creator and sent to distributors such as Penguinmagic and Theory11, it's out of their hands and the use and application of it is not something that can be controlled anymore.
Don't take what I'm saying as gospel, and I am interested to see what Mr. Vogt and Mr. Bayme have to say on the issue; but I think it would be okay to perform the trick. So long as you don't claim to say that the trick is yours. Lest you become a leper of the magic community