Okay, any suggestions for next year? (Then I would have enough time to get comfortable with something) Or would this just not work?
The biggest problem of why you aren't getting the results you are looking for is that no one knows how long you've been doing magic, what magic you want to do, and what magic you do know. And worse that you're taking the suggestions from here and taking the ones you like.
Good enough is not good magic.
Where we are standing right now, no one knows how to help you.
A year is a long time and a lot can happen from now until then. Theoretically, with enough dedication and focus, you could do the Valentine's Day thing in a few weeks.
You're only going to get your answers by researching tricks on your own and seeing what strikes your interest.
I don't want to say you're going uphill with rollerskates. But from now until then; you have to research tricks, select a trick, practice said trick, master the trick, create a good routine, and practice the routine until you're comfortable with it.
If this was two months from now--ok.
But a few weeks to do all this from scratch, to me, is a helluva tall order.