I think the thing to consider here is that Instagram/YouTube magic is a niche market that magic companies are active catering towards.
What this means is means is that we have to have 'additional filters' when it comes to magic purchases.
Personally, I acquire my magic on a shoestring budget. So any choices I do make HAVE to be ones that I'm absolutely certain that I will be using AND ones where I can deduce how it can be applied by the trailer and a bit of research.
With 'Instagram magic', which is something I believe 'Acme Hole' falls under. I don't think a live performance is necessary for a proof of concept in a trailer. Because, from what it sounds like, it can't hold water in a live performance. BUT, under the right conditions, can be filmed so that it looks flawless.
Instagram magic is the new market now.
And with that, I will say that when we are shopping around for magic and have just the trailers to go off of, the big thing to keep in mind is what they AREN'T telling or showing you.
In this case, no live performance. Another thing to look for: camera angles. Is every shot of the trick being done at a certain angle?
I wild encourage more people to watch trailers and try and figure out what REALLY is going on. Sometimes, you can figure out the entire trick by the trailer. Other times, you can figure out enough to determine if it's worth purchasing now, wait for reviews to make a purchase, or not at all.
It helps broadening ones knowledge in magic to be able to notice (pun intended) 'sleight things'.