Hey,
I perform almost entirely non-card magic. The "best" in my opinion are the following...
- Stitched by Alexander Kölle (It's organic, it's situational, and it's impossible)
- 5 & 1 Transpo by Jay Noblezada (Happens in the spectators hands and its super visual)
- Visibill by Richard Sanders (Borrowed bill, complete miracle, empty hands. This is something I have on me 24/7 and when I need to do an effect, I have this as my go-to)
- Thread by Wayne Houchin (Shockingly visual, and often disgusting. This effect leaves a powerful image in the minds of spectators)
- Cornered by Joshua Jay (I don't perform this effect as much as I do the others. But this is an effect that really gets under your spectators skin. It's an impossible effect with a borrowed bill)
- Smoke by Alan Rorrison (Simple, beautiful, quick. It's a definite worker and it hits hard)
Keep in mind those are just my favorite non-card effects. Also I find that if you really want to liven up your repertoire, keep utility devices on you at all times. Like if I just carry a TT on me, I can literally do 20+ different effects with the thing. Same goes for the raven, and TKO 2.0. Having these on you will allow you to perform tons of seemingly impromptu non-card effects. Hope this helped!
JP