I smell something fishy

[trickyman]

I noticed (as most of us did) that on the SMOKE&MIRRORSv5 page there are 22 reviews! Now if you look at the date one them... Well some of them are from 2008. I think that they moved all of the reviews from v4 to v5. And if you look on the "Playing Cards" page, SMOKE&MIRRORSv4 is gone.

I could be completely wrong but that's what I think.

 

[trickyman]

And I'm not saying that changes anything, that just my thoughts

 

[mehar]

I think you're right... then again, they didn't change anything except the color, right? So the reviews wouldn't have a reason to change.

 

[DanceOfCards]

I saw a post where they said that the finish and stock was exactly the same, so aside from aesthetics and the box the reviews should be reliable for v5's

 

[S.G]

They Do this with all decks of cards. The stingers have the v1 reviews too.

 

[saborfang17]

I noticed (as most of us did) that on the SMOKE&MIRRORSv5 page there are 22 reviews! Now if you look at the date one them... Well some of them are from 2008. I think that they moved all of the reviews from v4 to v5. And if you look on the "Playing Cards" page, SMOKE&MIRRORSv4 is gone.

I could be completely wrong but that's what I think.

Why would they keep S&M v4s up when those are sold out and v5s are in stock? And they've moved all the reviews over for all the cards...

 

[j.bayme]

The S&Mv5 share the same product page that the four editions before it occupied. If we created a new product page with each reprinting of a deck, we'd have about 10 pages for the Guardians and two in the past four weeks for the Sentinels. I don't believe that is efficient. The product reviews you see for the Smoke & Mirrors are for all editions, not just the latest printing.

 

[Infected]

you are absollutely right.

i knew it!

 

[JDENredden]

The S&Mv5 share the same product page that the four editions before it occupied. If we created a new product page with each reprinting of a deck, we'd have about 10 pages for the Guardians and two in the past four weeks for the Sentinels. I don't believe that is efficient. The product reviews you see for the Smoke & Mirrors are for all editions, not just the latest printing.

Are newer reviews of more current editions ranked higher than older ones?

J.