The one thing that shot out to me was that both of you need to work on your Spin Doctor. It was just too obvious that more than one card was being taken out, lol. It should be quick, smooth and flourishy, you're just meant to spin it out of the deck with one finger, rather than grabbing the double and pulling it out, which actually makes the whole move harder. Other than that Jake's doubles were awesome throughout.
Other than that the chicken suit FTW in my opinion. I preferred Jake's handling though, but the patter was just......ugh and I started to lose track of what the heck was going on after a point and I know the trick, lol.
Basically, Jake in my opinion had the better handling, but the chicken suit had the better performance, and kept it simple and impacting.
So my vote went to the Chicken, lol.