Yes be original but don't write off an entire category of props because they look like they are aimed at kids
I'm writing those props off because they look like they came from a magic shop, not because they are aimed at kids. Hippty Hoppity Rabbits, Run Rabbit Run and Stratosphere do not look like anything that kids have played with since the 1950s. They just look like something you bought at a magic shop.
If you do your job right the adults watching are going to be thinking 'those kids are having a great time and that performer is really good at their job' .
I strongly disagree. The adults are thinking, "what a dolt doing that stupid stuff with the kids, he really isn't a magician, but I guess the kids like him."
That line is typically used by children's "entertainers" who rely on self-working magic props and the same hackneyed jokes -"no the clean hand..." Most magicians that use that line think that by getting laughs for acting like a clownaid enough. Those magicians use nice terms like "magician in trouble" or "look don't see" but it is just acting like an idiot. Yeah, kids like it, but why make your magic show the equivalent of a Sponge Bob episode.
Shouldn't you strive to have the adults go, "Wow, he's a really good magician. That's almost like real magic."
To be a good children's magician you need to combine strong presentation and strong magic.
If the audience is thinking that they could just go pick up a few props and do your act it is more than likely that it is your performance that needs work, not because you have some props that look like they were designed with kids in mind.
How many people walk out of an illusion show saying -"it was the box, it was a trick box -it has to be.". The same thing with a dove pan. The same for the other magic shop props. It 's the box or it's the bag is usually the correct explanation.
As for presentation, I've seen magic coloring book slaughtered by too many Silly Billly clones and people using say do see patter.
My question for a children's magicians is what is your show about? Typically it is a series of tricks that the magician can do, but the children can't figure out presented by a clown. Why be like everybody else?