So... by your logic I should be able to go out tonight, buy a lotto ticket, and just because I buy a ticket win the lotto? I'm sorry Benji but reality doesn't work like that.
With all other factors removed from my control, the chance of me winning, and the probability of me losing lay in pure luck as no other factor I can apply any degree of control over can help affect or influence the eventual outcome with the possibility of increasing my chances by buying more tickets.
JUST buying a ticket doesn't guarantee one outcome over another. So by just taking action alone isn't enough. Now what you -are- trying to drill down at is the motivational message that actions get results, and by taking action you can influence the results (in or against your favor), and doubly so over not taking action, however your choice of a lottery analogy is flawed and inaccurate.
I get what you are trying to do, I just think you could do a better job of it.
Back on the subject of power of belief, someone who doesn't believe in luck I have to ask: What do you call the medical miracles that take place in hospitals around the world where someone gets healed completely (by medical definitions) of deadly, or terminal conditions that have left the doctors with no other way to deal with it other than accept defeat? If that's not luck, by literal application of your definition, then by all means what do you call it?
William, you're a man after my own heart here. . .
As I mentioned earlier, you can follow "the book" detail by detail, mimic any number of others that find success in any given field and still not find the same level of progress and accomplishment. The successful people in the world are blinded to the fact that we are all different and too, if everyone could "win" there would be no segregation of
haves & have nots on this planet. . . something about 99% keeps ringing in the back of my mind. . .
Yes, the majority of us could generate an ok living doing magic provided we are willing to sacrifice the trappings of normalcy in life; it is a very time consuming job that requires us to wear numerous hats; something that few of us are capable of doing. More so, fewer of us are willing to pay the price. Then we have that lottery ticket factor you've brought out and the fact that no one can win unless they play. . . I've watched many an already poor person end up in worse life settings and circumstances as the result of playing with the hope of winning. . . be it the lotto or some casino trap. In short, the odds are always against you and only a select and "Lucky" few ever seem to reap the rewards; typically due to political ladder climbing and simply being in the right place at the right time.
When it comes to the Miraculous as you and others already know, I believe in such phenomena in that I've seen it happen as well as experienced such things. Snicker all you wish (many do) but this world is filled with amazing things science cannot explain; phenomena that defies their collection of theories and "laws" that quite purposely gets swept under any nearby carpet . . . and we're not talking about PSI, the Power of Faith, etc. just general phenomena. But when it comes to the Paranormal, even here we find that science (no magicians) can explain certain things away; they have learned to obfuscate things and graciously (most of the time) skirt around and change the issue, but their only explanations seem to be "Coincidence", "Self-Fulfilling Prophecy" or "Cold Reading" the latter putting Randi himself in the hot-seat recently in that he couldn't answer questions about the differing facets of Astrology and the fact that NONE of the testing accepted by skeptics, were inclusive of the variables common to traditional Astrology. . . his solution was to have the "trouble makers" barred from the second half of the lecture.
Sorry but the evangelic trend of today's skeptics, especially from within the magic community, has done more to hurt their cause than help. It has created a very bold dividing line that more or less forces the believers of the community to "hide" and not speak up about their beliefs out of fear of being ridiculed and seen as a "fool". I've been one of the few to do the opposite for most of the past twenty years and slowly more and more are saying they've had enough as well. So stand tall William, your points about the miraculous will not fall on deaf ears and could quite well prove inspiration to the timid, giving them permission to stand up as well.
As I've already said, Yes one can make a living in magic, the question is however, what are you willing to sacrifice in order to do so. I'm one of the fools that lost everything because of my dedication to this particular mistress. I'm not alone, in a recent conversation with an old friend of mine (he was an old timer when I was in my 20s) we looked at how many of the greats, major players and icons of magic, died broke. . . even Vernon, his funeral was paid for by Copperfield after his livelihood had been sustained by the Castle & the Larsen family for over 30 years. This is that part of our industry you rarely hear about, especially when you have so many gung-ho sorts spitting out the latest version of Dale Carnegie or, as it would be now days, Tony Robbins.
Allow your magic to be a profitable hobby and then, once you've put that 25+ years in on the day job, then you can go out and do your thing, have some fun and allow your passion to support you in your silver & golden years. The most successful people I've known in this craft did it exactly this way.