Comparison of playing cards (out of 10)

[DLeerium]

Before I get flamed to use the search button, rest assured that I already have, and I would like a collective review on all cards. I would like to see how everyone rate their cards, a mark out of 10. Not so much the appearance but more on how the cards handle.

I understand that everyone has a different opinion on everything so It would be good to establish a baseline and say that Standard Bicycle Rider backs are 7/10.

Here are mine:

Blue and Red Wynns: 6.5/10
Bicycle Rider backs: 7/10
Aladdin 1001: 7.5/10
Brown Wynns: 7.5/10
Bicycle Guardians: 8/10 (same for centurions)
Ghosts: 8.5
Tally Ho #9: 9/10
Split Spade Lions: 9/10

I would greatly appreciate everyone's input =D

 

[The Tumbleweed]

Blue and Red Wynns: 8/10
Bicycle Rider backs: 7/10
Aladdin 1001: 7/10
Brown Wynns: 8/10
Bicycle Guardians: 9/10 (same for centurions)
Ghosts: 9
Tally Ho #9: 8.5/10
Split Spade Lions: 9/10
Smoke & Mirrors: 9.5/10

 

[b+w]

Arrcos- 8.5/10
Split Spades Lions- 9/10
Tally Ho- 9/10
Smoke and Mirrors- 9.5/10
Aladdin 1001- 7/10
Red and Blue Wynns- 6/10
Bicycle Vintages- 8.5/10
Centurions and Guardians- 8.5/10
Brown Wynns- 8/10

 

[Rasmus]

Bicycle Rider Back - 6/10
Tally Ho- 9/10
Aladdin 1001- 8/10
Red and Blue Wynns- 8/10
Fournier 505 - 8/10
Ellusionist thick blah blah tiger etc - 0,5/10

 

[LuseifHo]

Bicycle Rider Back - 7/10
Tally Ho - 7/10
Aladdin 1001 - 8.5/10
Red/ Blue Wynns - 7/10
Bees - 6/10
Bicycle League Backs - 6/10
Ellusionist UV 500s - 8/10
Absolut Vodkas - 8.5/10
Guardian - 9/10
Centurions - 8/10
Props 7.5/10
Arrco - 8.5 /10
Studs - 8.5/10
Karnivals - 8.5/10
Tragic Deck - 4/10
Most novelty bikes (aids, pink, powderblue, etc) - 5/10
Lions - 8.5/10
Brown Wynn - 8.5 / 10
S&M - 9/10
Ramblers - 6/10
Jerry's - 8.5 / 10
Dr. Leons - 9/10
Split Spades -8/10
White Cents - 8/10
Plastic Novelty Cards (as in clear/ see through) - 3/10
Rainbow Bikes - 6.5/10

 

[LuseifHo]

Ellusionist thick blah blah tiger etc - 0,5/10

That is an extremely stupid thing to say.
Any idiot who handles cards know that they arent 0.5/10
Please grow up.

 

[spades]

Assuming that bikes are 7/10...
Bicycle rider back - 7/10
Tally-ho - 7.5/10
Wynn's 10/10 (just me, love Wynn's)
Guardians - 8/10
Ghosts - 8/10
Split spades - 8.5/10
Karnivals - 8.5/10

 

[chriswiehl]

Smoke & Mirrors: 9.5/10

I agree with the SMoke and Mirrors. They are real great lol.

 

[Haavard]

Bicycle Rider backs: 7.5/10
Brown Wynns: 7.5/10
Bicycle Guardians: 8/10
Ellusionist decks: 6/10
Tally Ho #9: 9/10
Split Spade Lions: 9/10

 

[tally-ho]

Tally-ho - 9.9/10 - still have not found the perfect deck, but this is pretty close.
Bicycle rider back - 6/10
Bee - 7/10
Stud - 8/10
Centurions/guardians - 6-7/10
Aristocrat - 6/10
Carta mundi - 4-5/10
Ghost - 7.5/10
Wynn - blue - 7/10
Split spades 8/10

This is based on what I use them for, not in general. Sorry.

 

[DLeerium]

Tally-ho - 9.9/10 - still have not found the perfect deck, but this is pretty close.
Bicycle rider back - 6/10
Bee - 7/10
Stud - 8/10
Centurions/guardians - 6-7/10
Aristocrat - 6/10
Carta mundi - 4-5/10
Ghost - 7.5/10
Wynn - blue - 7/10
Split spades 8/10

This is based on what I use them for, not in general. Sorry.

loll not very biased that you rate tally ho 9.9 considering your name is tally-ho

Hahah Tally's are my favorite casual deck, however I am hearing great things about bicycle vintage.

 

[holo]

loll not very biased that you rate tally ho 9.9 considering your name is tally-ho

Hahah Tally's are my favorite casual deck, however I am hearing great things about bicycle vintage.

They both are great, but they are very different. Im not so sure how to describe it though.

 

[xaykogeki]

Standard Bikes = 7/10
Masters = 9/10 (I just love'em, and currently using);
Brown Wynns = 8/10 (Currently using);
Bicycle Guardians/Centurions = 8/10
Tally-Ho = 9/10 (Currently using);
Ghosts = 8.5/10
Split Spades = 8.5/10
Aladdin 100[2] = 3/10
Smoke and Mirrors = 8/10 (Too thick for me...or psychologically thick for me);
Tragic Royalty = 2/10 (They also smell weird...printing ink);
Series 1800 = 5/10 (but they look so old and cool);

 

[Jack Webster]

Ghost-8.5/10
Tally-ho-9/10
Split Spades-10/10
Guardians/cents-8/10
Massas-7/10
Brown Wynns-8.5/10
Dr.Leon-8/10
Smoke&Mirror-9/10
Propaganda-8/10
Pirate Playing Cards-9.5/10
Black tiger-8.5/10
Black Ghost-8.5/10
Tally-Ho vipers-8/10
Karnival deck-6.5/10
Bees-7.5/10
Masters-8.5/10
Shadow Masters-9/10
Series 1800-5/10
tragic royalty-5/10

 

[Axe]

Bicycle Vintage Fan backs:: 9/10
Arrco:: 8/10
Aladdin::8/10(air-cushion)
Smoke and Mirror:: 8.5/10
Tally-Ho:: 7/10
Bicycle Eagles:: 9/10
Aviator:: 6/10
Ghost:: 6.5/10
Black Tiger:: 4/10
Bicycle Guardian::5/10
Bicycle Centurions:: 5/10
White Centurions:: 7/10
Bicycle Eco:: 7.5/10
Wynns:: 5.5/10
Massas:: 8/10
Propaganda:: 8.5/10
WPT:: 9/10
Old Studs:: 9/10
Newer Studs:: 7.5/10
Aladdin:: 6/10 (non-air-cushion)
Bicycle poker peek:: 6/10
Monte Carlo:: 4/10
Jerrys Nuggets:: 9.5/10
Bee:: 7/10
Bicycle Vintage 1800(Ellusionist):: 3/10
Bicycle Tragic Royalty:: 2.5/10J
Shadow Masters:: 6.5/10
Split Spade Lions:: 8.5/10
Viper(Ellusionist):: 6/10

Note:: I will update this with more,as I think of them=)

-Alex

 

[P8NTBALLDADDY]

I think with most cards like Karnivals, Theory11, Ellusionist. I have had good and bad batches.

 

[Zeedub81]

Before I get flamed to use the search button, rest assured that I already have, and I would like a collective review on all cards. I would like to see how everyone rate their cards, a mark out of 10. Not so much the appearance but more on how the cards handle.

I understand that everyone has a different opinion on everything so It would be good to establish a baseline and say that Standard Bicycle Rider backs are 7/10.

Here are mine:

Blue and Red Wynns: 6.5/10
Bicycle Rider backs: 7/10
Aladdin 1001: 7.5/10
Brown Wynns: 7.5/10
Bicycle Guardians: 8/10 (same for centurions)
Ghosts: 8.5
Tally Ho #9: 9/10
Split Spade Lions: 9/10

I would greatly appreciate everyone's input =D

All wynns: 6/10 -just to let you know, regardless of color, all wynns have the same stock and finish
Guardians: 7/10
Ghosts/all other E decks(except Vintage 1800): 8/10
Vintage 1800: 5.5/10
Tally Ho: 7/10
Split Spade Lions: 8.8/10
Massas: 6.5/10
Propaganda: 7.7/10
Eco Edition: 6/10

 

[LuseifHo]

I think with most cards like Karnivals, Theory11, Ellusionist. I have had good and bad batches.

indeed
I have a godly deck of Guardian and Karnis.
They both fan perfectly even when done really slowly.
Normal decks clump if you fan slowly.
My guardian is my first guardian deck from when they came out and it still feels like heaven. haha
kinda awesome!
haha.

 

[phrozunsun]

I think with most cards like Karnivals, Theory11, Ellusionist. I have had good and bad batches.

I think it's more about storage and handling. Think of decks of cards like cigars and bottles of wine....

 

[aJohnson]

All wynns: 6/10 -just to let you know, regardless of color, all wynns have the same stock and finish
Guardians: 7/10
Ghosts/all other E decks(except Vintage 1800): 8/10
Vintage 1800: 5.5/10
Tally Ho: 7/10
Split Spade Lions: 8.8/10
Massas: 6.5/10
Propaganda: 7.7/10
Eco Edition: 6/10

So you rate Wynn's all the same? Even though Violet Wynns are alot better than Red Wynns at fans.