Practice is the most important thing in any art. practice is to magic as drawing is to fine art. it is foundation.
Keep in mind,in magic,performance is the BEST way to practice.
Unless all one does is move monkey card tricks then yeah,practicing independently is just as well.
That is very true, but (not to start an argument) without practicng first performance will bear no fruit.
Its not an argument. Its a discussion.
Well like your analogy,the art student always displays his first work.And it is obviously novice. But through it being displayed the audience,teacher,helps him in improving his art. (in magic,that being the reactions and what/how the audience say what they say)
Which is tons more efficient than the student drawing home alone and just keeps drawing and drawing and will never know what is wrong or how he can improve.
Hmm... very good point. Just to continue the discussion, the student must have a basis first. If I saw someone do... the time travel card, and then went out right then (knowing the method but not practicing) and performed it, it wouldnt be pretty. A small basis is needed, then performance hones the skills in the best way possible.