The only consideration is whether the audience will be able to understand (notice I didn't say "see") what is happening. A stage show for 35 is different from a stage show for 50 and is different from a stage show for 500.
I agree with
@Josh Burch that you don't have to rule out cards and don't have to use jumbo cards. If you are a good performer, you can perform anything on stage. Look for videos of Wayne Dobson (and his book WD-40 is great) on YouTube - especially his sponge ball routine.
I disagree with
@Bryant_Tsu, Linking Rings can be great on stage. Unfortunately, most performers structure and present that routine badly - primarily because they downplay the strength of the magic by linking the rings in a matter of fact manner or present the effect as a look what I can do that this spectator can't. Also, I really can't say that the linking rings IS overused... I actually have never seen a live performance of it (other than my own). Bowling ball productions and floating tables - seen way too many time - never performed well.
Find material that you like to perform that can be understood by everyone. You can go from low budget to grand illusions. Off the top of my head, a low budget stage show could include:
5 Card Opener
Tossed Out Deck
Sponge Balls
Slydini's Flight of the Paper Balls
Baffeling Bra (tasteful performance using a married couple)
Eric Ross's Election (using same couple to show a connection)
Wayne Dobson's Teach
David Regal's Clink
Invisible Deck (get the audience involved in selecting the card - don't use the regular presentation)
My stage/parlor show can (depending on the composition of the audience and amount of time) include the following effects (some of which are still works in progress)
Linking Rings or Waking's Billard Ball Routine (done to music)
Steinmeyer's Pasteboards Under Glass
My Own Bill in Lemon(ade) Effect
Steinmeyer's Fan Mail
Eric Ross's Election (Using a married couple focusing on whether it is better to be alike or different)
Steinmeyer's Apples and Oranges
Misers Dream (with ice and champagne bottle production)
Sands of the Dessert
Margarites Wishes (my own egg bag routine set to a story)