Okay, I normally suck at these kind of things, but here's my guesses.
FACTS:
1. He was born with a black eye and every once in a while his eye closes unintentionally.
Blake Vogt
2. He once bought a piece of toast without the image of Jesus on it for $50.00.
Sounds like something Andrei Jikh would do
3. His nickname is Momo.
Chris Mayhew
4. He has a fish name Paul Vigil.
Alex Geiser
5. He is addicted to horror movies.
Dan White
6. He owns a banana signed by Fred Durst which has been preserved in a plastic baggy since 1999.
Mike Hankins
7. He used to give tours of the Vatican.
Eric Ross
8. He once cried in the middle of a bar while ten people watched in confusion.
B. Smith
9. He played the lead of two middle school plays
Calen Morelli
... Now we play the waiting game to see who wins!